|
Question |
Assalaam o Alaikum, kindly shed some light over on following matters. ....
If music is Haram or not permissible in Islaam so what about Naat, qawali ,noha & manqabat ????.
i would request you to please first understand my question than answer me spacifically.......... do not refer me any link in replying to my question..... as i have already gone through all the links available on internet..... but i didnt find any asnwer regarding the same.........and secondly , please donot use any jargons like "(ghina) " or "(lohv o laeb ki mehfiloo)" & etc..... please answer me like any layman whos weak in urdu can easily understand you answer ............ thats why i am asking here so that my & my brothers /sisters out there those are connected to music fileds or like wise reciting naat, qawali noha & manqabat, once & for all their confusion can be cleared ..... answer me or help me as soon as possible i will be very thankful to you forever.
Sir, let me tell you one more thing here that i am a musician & i play all kind of musical instruments.
if you see, 99% naat, hamd, manqabat & nohay are tuned & has melody you can play their tunes on any musical instruments and people easily recognized that what is being played over on keyboards or on guitar etc.....
OK! for your better understanding I make it more spacify/elaborate for you...
1. Bhar dou jholi mere ya Mohammad lot kar main na jaunga khali ( Qawali, sung by many qawal )....
2. Ali kay saath hai Zahra ke Shadi (Manqabat , recited by many nohan khaun like nadeem sarver etc)....
3. Zakhm e dil dikhain ge jab imaam aainge ( Noha, recited by nadeem sarvar & sibt e jafer) .....
4. Na Ro Zainab na ro mere jigar k tukre na ro ( noha)......
5. Mohammad ka roza qareeb aa raha hai ( Naat, by Junaid Jamshed)....
Sir mentioned above all Nohay, manqabat, naat & qawali are 110% melodious, tuned & if the person who has little music knowledge can easily undertand that these are on musical scale and any listener can easly recognized what is beeing play .......
when i play piano or guitar .......without saying any single word to my wife , to my kids & to my friends they can easily recognized what is beeing played over on guitar.....
2 , 3 day i was playing noha ( GHABRA E ZAINAB ) & (MUJH PAY KIYON BAND KARTE Ho PAANI )
|
|
Answer |
Wssalam o alykum, The music (mosiqi o gina) is classified in halaal music and haraam music, (Ref : aqa sistani,Jadeed faqhi masail , masala # 544 , pg # 277 , eidition # 5).
If the music depends on false conversation and words (which conversation and words are not permissible in Islam like tell a lay ect) or way (tune) of speaking this conversation and words is played in speaking way of those who are the jocular persons and fornicator persons so this music is haraam, except it all is halaal. (Ref : Mujtahid se pochay gaey sawalaat, part # 2 , sawaal # 216 , pg # 86).
And to talk about the Nooha, Naat ect so if these depend on right conversation and words and tune of these are not the tune of those who are the jocular and fornicator person so it is halaal what ever it is being played by the same instrument, Right if you know that it depend on false conversation and words or the tune of it is tune of jucular and fornicator so you can not listen or play it. (Ref : Mujtahid se pochay gaey sawalaat, part # 2 , sawaal # 218 , pg # 87) , (Ref : aqa sistani,Jadeed faqhi masail , masala # 551 , pg # 278 , eidition # 5 , Allah Taala hi tofiqaat main izafa farmaane wala hai). |